Wanderers 1 Old Etonians 1 (after extra time)
Played March 11 1876, Attendance 3,500, Referee WS Rawson
Wanderers Team
William D O Greig, Alfred Hugh Stratford, William Lindsay, Frederick Brunning Chappel-Maddison, Francis Hornby Birley, Charles Henry Reynolds Wollaston, Charles Francis William Heron, George Hubert Hugh Heron, John Edwards (Scored), Jarvis Kenrick, Thomas Hughes
Old Etonians Team
Quintin Hogg, Reverand James E C Welldon, Hon Edward Lyttleton, Albert Thompson, Hon Arthur Kinnaird (Captain), C Meysey, William Stanley Kenyon-Slaney, Hon Alfred Lyttleton, Julian Sturgis, Alexander George Bonsor (Scored), Herbert Allene
1876 FA Cup Final Replay Result
Wanderers 3 Old Etonians 0
Replay Played March 18 1876, Attendance 1,500, Referee WS Rawson
Wanderers Team
William D O Greig, Alfred Hugh Stratford, William Lindsay, Frederick Brunning Chappel-Maddison, Francis Hornby Birley, Charles Henry Reynolds Wollaston (Scored), Charles Francis William Heron, George Hubert Hugh Heron, John Edwards, Jarvis Kenrick, Thomas Hughes (Scored (2))
Old Etonians Team
Quintin Hogg, Edgar Lubbock, Hon Edward Lyttleton, Matthew Farrer, Hon Arthur Kinnaird (Captain), (Sir) James Stronge, William Stanley Kenyon-Slaney, Hon Alfred Lyttleton, Julian Sturgis, Alexander George Bonsor, Herbert Allene
